My first experience with Botch wasn't through seeing them live or hearing them on record. It was through 'Edge Of Quarrel'. If you're not familiar with it, 'Edge Of Quarrel' is a low budget take on 'West Side Story' which sees crusty punks pitched against straightedgers. There was a time when this was the hot topic for hardcore punks and you'd always end up watching it at punk's houses. It is pretty laughable and is in the so bad I enjoyed it category. The 6.6 rating on IMDb is extremely generous but the music in it is fucking great. Trial and Undertow I already knew but it also introduced me to Botch and The Murder City Devils.
This neatly brings me on to tonight's opening act, Great Falls. Great Falls feature Undertow's Demian Johnston on guitar. Undertow are still revered by a number of hardcore kids of a certain age, myself included. They're one of the pioneers of metallic hardcore. Their music hasn't aged at all. However, most importantly, they never sullied their legacy with endless reunions and continuing way past their prime releasing records which increasingly reduce in quality.
A guitar riff rings out, played slowly with plenty of space to breathe whilst Demian yells into the audience without a mic to open Great Falls' set. Despite the size of the venue, this has a DIY feel and takes me back to the hardcore shows of the 90s, which is apt when you consider their heritage. When the rest of the band kick in for the track 'Dragged Home Alive', they play heavy, technical noisy hardcore with complex time changes reminiscent of Deadguy or Kiss It Goodbye (who Demian was also a member of). The second track is more chaotic with riffs which come in waves, reminiscent of tonight's headliners or maybe even Dragbody. The band only met guest vocalist, Lillian Albazi, the previous day even though she appears on the album. You can't always hear her vocals so her presence seems a bit superfluous at times but when the vocals are audible, they add a Swans edge to the noise. Their more repetitive, hypnotic moments are at the beginning and end of the set and they are more Om or Bell Witch influenced in those moments. Overall, this is a committed performance and the bassist in particular really attacks his instrument with conviction. Really, really impressive.
There is a huge air of anticipation for Botch tonight. This is a pretty big venue and most people probably never thought they'd get the opportunity to see them live as they didn't tour that much over here when they were a functioning band and most people discovered them after they'd split anyway. I'm probably in the minority that I have seen them before and I'm nervous rather than excited. I saw them just after they'd released 'We Are The Romans' at a small pub in Leeds and they absolutely blew my mind. I went mainly for the support bands, Canvas and Thirty Seconds Until Armageddon, who were two of the finest heavy hardcore bands the UK had to offer. Botch played much of the set in absolute darkness whilst I was assaulted by waves and waves of noise. When the lights were on, they strobed in time to the music. It was very intense, so much so that I had to sit down at the back at one point. The perfect synthesis of music and show which is why I'm nervous now. Can they replicate that same feeling in a much larger venue?
Opening properly with the jagged, discordant riffs, twisted time signatures and shredded throat vocals of 'Our Friends In The Great White North', it is soon clear that this is still the Botch I remember. The anticipation of the packed hall is converted into genuine electric excitement. People are losing their minds to these songs which previously they've just listened to studio recordings of. 'Mondrian Was A Liar' features more of the light show which I expected, only its impact is slightly lessened because of the size of the venue and the bar lights. It seems even heavier live, which is admirable considering this is something which they're already renowned for. 'Spaim' leading into 'Japam' sees jagged riffs carried along by rumbling bass into a positively rocking groove. There's a big Deadguy influence in various parts. One moment is Nordic Giants style cinematic post rock and it has a similar emotional heft. I can see quite a bit of movement in front of me for the bouncy yet quirky noise rock of 'One Twenty Two'. I was a bit concerned about how they would sound in such a big venue but I needn't have worried because the sound fills the venue amazingly well. Encore 'Afghamistam' is a change of pace with Dave Verellen gently singing amid some orchestral touches and this again has a Nordic Giants feel. The following track 'C. Thomas Howell As The Soul Man' sounds super loud and intense in contrast. Twenty five years on and there may be a bigger audience but this is still the same band. The final track 'Saint Matthew Returns To the Womb' is urgent and dynamic, and is a fitting way to end a fantastic return.
Botch ****
Great Falls ****

























